Chapter 9: Processes by Appointment Type
Chapter 9: Processes by Appointment Type
Table of ContentsPrevious ChapterNext Chapter
Initial appointments, reappointments, and promotions of faculty are initiated by the department chair/director. For any faculty appointment action, the faculty member should consult with the chair/director of the academic department, center, or institute in which their primary appointment resides. The School of Medicine’s Required Paperwork provides specifics on documentation required for appointment, promotion, or reappointment.
9.1 Academic Appointments
For initial appointments, reappointments, and promotions of academic faculty, the recommendation of the chair/director, accompanied by the required documents, is presented to the Vice Dean of Academic Affairs. Appointments up to and including Assistant Professor will be reported to the MEDSAC. Senior faculty appointments will be reviewed by the Steering Committee of the MEDSAC for review and recommendation. If there are questions about the appointment or the documentation, the VDAA will return the recommendation with comments to the chair/director. If the recommendation of the chair/director and the supporting documentation are in order, and if the VDAA approves, one of the following procedures will be initiated.
For initial appointments and promotions of academic faculty to the rank of Associate Professor or Professor, and for the granting of tenure, the VDAA will appoint an ad hoc committee of faculty to review the recommendation and the supporting documentation received from the chair/director. This committee will normally consist of three members of the full- or part-time faculty whose academic rank is equal to or higher than the candidate’s proposed rank. Faculty from the candidate’s own academic department, center, or institute are not eligible to serve on the ad hoc committee. The chair of the ad hoc committee will be a regular member of the Steering Committee. Other members of ad hoc committees are selected by the VDAA from the faculty at large to provide appropriate balance with respect to discipline, research focus, and activity components. The ad hoc committee’s deliberations are confidential.
The VDAA may assign a faculty member as an observer of the Steering Committee’s and/or an ad hoc committee’s deliberations on the condition that strict confidentiality will be maintained. Such faculty will be selected from a list submitted by chairs or directors.
The ad hoc committee will review the material submitted by the chair/director and may solicit additional information considered of value in reaching a judgment. This may include additional information from the chair/director, other faculty in the school, or elsewhere in the University. Further, the committee may seek to obtain, through the VDAA, its own evaluation of the candidate from persons in other institutions in addition to any persons previously contacted by the recommending chair/director. These referees are selected based on their scholarship and expertise in the relevant field and should not be individuals who are: present or past colleagues at the same institution as students or trainees; collaborators on grants or research projects within the last three years; prior mentors, colleagues or faculty from the candidate’s training institution(s); members of the candidate’s thesis committee; prior practice or research partners; prior business associates, or family members. The ad hoc committee will judge the evidence in support of the appointment or promotion based on whether the criteria are met for the identified activity components.
The ad hoc committee will submit a written confidential report to the VDAA. The report should include a description of all documents reviewed, the committee’s activities in gathering information, a critical evaluation of the available information, and a recommendation with respect to the proposed appointment or promotion.
If the ad hoc committee concurs with the chair/director’s recommendation with respect to the appointment or promotion, the report will be presented to and reviewed by the Steering Committee in accordance with review procedures established by that committee. Before making a final recommendation, the Steering Committee may request, through the VDAA, additional information or seek to clarify the basis of the department, center, or institute’s decision to request consideration of the specified activity components. For faculty actions, a minimum of 13 of the 24 voting members of the Steering Committee must be in attendance for a quorum. A YES vote by three- quarters of those present will be considered a positive or favorable vote. The Steering Committee’s vote on the proposed departmental or center recommendation will be recorded and is advisory to the Dean. The Steering Committee’s recommendation and a summary of any relevant discussion points will be communicated by the VDAA to the chair/director, in writing, and the Dean will be advised as such. The VDAA will transmit the ad hoc committee’s report, void of ad hoc members’ names, to the chair/director who, in turn, will convey the essence of the committee’s assessment and recommendation to the faculty member.
If the ad hoc committee disagrees with the department’s recommendation, the chair/director will be informed by the VDAA, and has the following options: 1) accept the ad hoc committee’s report and recommendation without challenge; 2) provide further documentation to the VDAA in support of the faculty action and request reconsideration of the case by the ad hoc committee; or 3) appeal directly to the Steering Committee, in writing, with or without additional documentation. Depending on the outcome of this appeal, the case may be appealed directly to the full MEDSAC.
If the Steering Committee’s recommendation with respect to the proposed action disagrees with the department, center, or institute’s or the ad hoc committee’s recommendation, the VDAA shall report to the chair/director the substance of the Steering Committee’s comments and will include in the communication the final vote tally on the department, center, or institute’s original proposal or on any alternative recommendations made by the Steering Committee. The chair/director at this point may: 1) withdraw the recommendation for appointment or promotion; 2) accept an alternative recommendation, if any, that the Steering Committee may make; 3) assemble additional documentation in support of the original department, center, or institute recommendation and request reconsideration by the Steering Committee; or 4) appeal the decision, in writing, to the full MEDSAC, with or without additional documentation.
With the Dean’s concurrence, positive Steering Committee recommendations for appointments and promotions will be presented to the full MEDSAC for information, then forwarded to the Provost for Associate Professors and Professors, and the Board of Trustees (for tenure cases) for approval. Negative Steering Committee recommendations will be returned to the department, center, or institute for further action.
For reappointment as Associate Professor or Professor, or for a proposed change in status (e.g., from part-time to full-time or appointment type), if the VDAA concurs with the chair/director’s recommendation the case will be reviewed by the Steering Committee in accordance with review procedures established by that committee. Before making a final recommendation, the Steering Committee may request additional information if needed, through the VDAA. For faculty actions, a minimum of 13 of the 24 voting members of the Steering Committee must be in attendance for a quorum. A ‘yes’ vote by three-quarters of those present will be considered supportive of the action. The Steering Committee’s vote on the proposed departmental or center recommendation will be recorded and is advisory to the Dean. The Steering Committee’s recommendation will be communicated by the VDAA to the chair/director, in writing, and the Dean will be advised as such.
When negative Steering Committee recommendations are subsequently appealed to the full MEDSAC, they will be presented by the chair/director for further discussion and a final recommendation by that body, provided that any additional information or documentation that the chair/director assembles and plans to present in support of the appeal must be first submitted to and reviewed by the Steering Committee. A written summary of the Steering Committee’s discussion of the case will be included as part of the documentation presented to MEDSAC, which will, in turn, judge the evidence in support of the candidate’s appointment or promotion and will make a recommendation advisory to the Dean. In cases involving tenure, once a recommendation is made by MEDSAC and the Dean concurs, it is considered final, and no further appeals are possible. In non-tenure cases, the department, center, or institute may elect to resubmit the case for consideration, after a period of two years, with or without a change in activity components for consideration.
The chair/director will provide periodic feedback to the faculty member, as necessary, regarding the status of the faculty member’s case as it progresses through the review process. The final decision concerning a faculty member’s appointment, reappointment, promotion, or tenure will be communicated to the faculty member, in writing, by the chair/director.
9.2 Professional, Service, Special, and Non-Academic Appointments
Initial appointments and promotions of these faculty are made on the recommendation of the chair/director to the Dean and to the MEDSAC, where appropriate. Appointments at the Associate Professor level and above require review and recommendation of the Steering Committee of the MEDSAC, approval of the Senior Vice President for Health Sciences and the Office of the Provost.