Contact
About Me
Faculty Appointments
Assistant Professor of Clinical Medicine (Part-Time) - Department of Medicine, Primary Care Physicians (SMD)
Credentials
Residency & Fellowship
Residency, Internal Medicine, University of Rochester Medical Center. 1986 - 1988
Internship, Obstetrics & Gynecology, University of Rochester Medical Center. 1985 - 1986
Education
MD | New York Medical College. 1985
Ratings & Comments
At URMC, we believe that patients should be empowered to make the right decisions regarding their personal healthcare. To do so, transparency is critical. URMC partners with Press Ganey, to survey our patients about all aspects of their care experience. We are now putting this pertinent information at your fingertips by displaying star ratings for our providers along with anonymous patient comments on our website. This will help you make better-informed choices about how and with whom you seek care. Click here to learn more about the surveys used to generate this vital information. Learn more about our survey process.
Ratings
Care provider's discussion of any proposed treatment (options, risks, benefits, etc.)
Likelihood of recommending this care provider to others
Explanations the care provider gave you about your problem or condition
Care provider's efforts to include you in decisions about your care
Concern the care provider showed for your questions or worries
Patient Comments
This doctor was wonderful. He listened and looked me in the eye when he spoke. He also wasn't rushed to get me out the door.
Oct 23, 2025
Excellent care provided. Could not ask for anything more.
Aug 27, 2025
I was very pleased with the Dr's care and manner.
Jul 08, 2025
Dr. Scheier was very professional and kind. Prescribed as needed.
Jun 29, 2025
It was Friday 9 AM. I called for an appointment My doctor was out of the office that day, but got in at 3 PM. I met with Dr. Scheier , He was very informative, and addressed the issue that I came in for which was a pinched nerve in the neck. Also, he took the time. To review other issues, serious issues I have happening. After spending time with Dr. Scheier, I wish all students that are in the medical program at URMC could spend the day working with him. He is a poised knowledgeable Dr. With excellent bedside manners, sincerity And clarity.
Mar 21, 2025
Dr Scheier was terrific!
Mar 15, 2025
The Doctor immediately put me at ease. He clearly had studied my files. This helped me relax, and have a fruitful discussion.
Feb 19, 2025
Doc did a great job explaining his thought process and making sure we were on the same page. It felt like a collaborative decision making process, which I really appreciate.
Feb 11, 2025
Dr. Neil Scheier was one of the kindest doctors I have ever visited, and excellent.
Jan 26, 2025
Outstanding doctors and pas
Jan 21, 2025
I would like to recommend Dr. Scheier. But I can't! He is only filling in to help out! He would be someone I would recommend and I wish he would join the practice. It was clear he had read my concerns and chart. He knew my surgeon and even one from many years ago. That personal touch is missing in medicine today.
Dec 16, 2024
Dr. Scheier was very interested in what I had to say and how I wanted to proceed.
Nov 08, 2024
Dr. Scheier was exceptional! I was nervous about seeing a locum who I'd never met before, but he immediately put me at ease, listened to my concerns, and thoughtfully suggested treatment options based on his years of experience. I would happily see him again in the future.
Oct 05, 2024
I felt my concerns were addressed It'll a timely fashion.
Sep 13, 2024
It was my Dr's day off so I saw a fill in Doctor. Although he was very pleasant I still have some questions in my mind. I know I had gout.. But then I worried about neuropathy in my feet and if physical therapy would help. Then I checked info for myself on the internet. I have been seeing Dr [...] for years and there is a trust that exists there. This visit leaves me with a feeling that I still need to have a conversation with her even if it is just a zoom call.
Sep 02, 2024
MD filling in for Dr. [...], really nice person.
Sep 01, 2024
Dr Scheier took his time with me. He asked about all my concerns and went through each one carefully.
Jul 22, 2024
So happy this Dr. Was available to see me and get medicine for me.
Jun 28, 2024
Absolutely fabulous DOCTOR. He was just filling in, yet he had reviewed my health record thoroughly and was prepared. Listened a tentatively and responded in a thoughtful professional manner. I wish very much that this doctor was still in practice today.
Jun 26, 2024
Overall, a very good experience.
Jun 26, 2024
Every one was so welcoming
Jun 20, 2024
I would like to see Dr. Scheier every visit [...]. He is excellent.
Jun 20, 2024
Good
Jun 07, 2024
Dr Scheier was very helpful to me
May 24, 2024
Everyone that I encounter at this provider's office is always kind, caring and friendly. I have confidence in the staff and provider's. I praise this office all the time
Apr 25, 2024
Stay the same all great
Apr 23, 2024
This was a sub doctor. He was very good.
Apr 22, 2024
I was pleasantly surprised with Dr. Scheier. Although I really like Dr. Judge, Dr. Scheier provided excellent care.
Apr 22, 2024
Provider listen carefully to what I was telling him as reflected in his extensive notes on MyChart
Apr 21, 2024
It was good
Apr 19, 2024
Experienced, caring, reassuring, knowledgable
Apr 17, 2024
My first time seeing Doctor Scheier. Was comfortable with him. Appreciated that he explained health matters to me and answered my questions.
Apr 16, 2024
Dr. Was outstanding in every aspect, a great example of what primary care physicians should be!
Apr 14, 2024
I like him.
Apr 07, 2024
My Dr. Is out on maternity leave and Dr. Scheirer was excellent-he had read my medical history and explained his diagnosis with great clarity. A wonderfully experienced and thorough Dr.
Mar 30, 2024
Dr. Neil Scheier(?sp) was a fill in to help out but had read my chart before coming in and was very thorough. You are very lucky to have him help out
Mar 28, 2024
For a sub doctor (+11 Dr....) it was a very good experience.
Mar 13, 2024
Dr. Scheier was very thorough, although this was the first time I saw him as he was filling in for my regular physician Dr. Meloni. Check out staff very courteous & welcoming.
Mar 13, 2024
Very thoughtful manner
Mar 08, 2024
All staff, nurses & doctor all were very pleasant.
Feb 15, 2024
I had an overall great experience given it was not my usual doctor.
Feb 15, 2024
Excellent manner, listened to my concerns, information received was helpful and reassuring
Feb 08, 2024
Dr Deiss is amazing and Dr Neil Scheier was also phenomenal.
Feb 07, 2024
Dr. Scheier is not my normal doctor but he showed care and compassion even though he did not know me.
Jan 25, 2024
Dr. Scheier is an excellent physician. He listens, Is extremely patient, and explains everything very thoroughly.
Jan 18, 2024
Dr. Scheier was absolutely wonderful during my appointment with him [...]! He was 'filling In' for the PA I usually see (who was on vacation); and this was my first time meeting Dr. Scheier. I was astounded by how detailed and thorough he was in addressing a medication issue related to my ongoing struggle to stabilize my hypertension. Dr. Scheier is a wealth of knowledge; included me in the discussion about changing my medication regimen; and was also incredibly kind and professional. Dr. Scheier is easily one of the best physicians from whom I have ever received care!
Dec 07, 2023
I've always been happy with Dr. Iacobucci's care, and that of his office staff. Dr. Scheier was filling in, and was absolutely wonderful. I went into my appointment feeling awful, nit to mention scared, and I walked out with an answer. A million thanks to all!
Sep 24, 2023
Dr. Scheier was wonderful, and Nurse Roseanne was too. Both were very helpful, personable and not at all rushed.
Sep 24, 2023
Exceeded all expectations!
Sep 24, 2023
Always have had a wonderful experience.
Jul 26, 2023
Always get excellent care.
Jul 26, 2023
Dr. Stornelli is my primary and he is awesome saw Dr. Scheier and he was awesome too.
Jul 26, 2023
This provider was exceptionally caring - more than the usual.
Jun 30, 2023
It restores my hope in my recent overall medical care, which has been heartless at best!
Jun 30, 2023
Be more careful to make sure I am given all follow-up info such as next appts. - date esp.
Jun 30, 2023
Even though Dr. Scheier was a "temp" fill in he was OUTSTANDING!
Jun 30, 2023
Dr. Neil Scheier was "filling in"/due to office staff shortage. Outstanding!
Jun 30, 2023
Very personable, friendly and caring. My first time ever with this fill in provider. I felt very comfortable talking about my issues with new medicines. He really listened. I always get white coat syndrome, even with my regular provider of over 30 years. I felt like he knew me forever as well!
Jun 23, 2023
[...] He was very professional and respectful, thorough and knowledgeable, but was not acquainted with us and so not familiar with the health issues. Secretarial staff were present and seemed to do the job they were given [...] My family has some serious health concerns and we have always (10 years +) been very very pleased with the care at this office. [...]
Apr 28, 2023
I would have liked to see my regular doctor but was very pleased I was able to see another, Neil Scheier was most helpful.
Apr 03, 2023
I was very pleased to get a prompt appointment even though it wasn't with my regular p/c dr. [...]
Apr 03, 2023
In general spend a little more time on each visit.
Mar 30, 2023
Visits are usually enjoyable. Have known them for years. Provider at this visit very "wooden".
Mar 07, 2023
I never had an issue. All Doctors, PA's and Nurses have been outstanding
Feb 24, 2023
This dr. was very thorough. He had read my history and knew what I had when he entered the room.
Feb 20, 2023
Very calm.
Feb 20, 2023
I always have a good experience w/ this practice. Dr Scheier was a "fill in" for my regular doctor.
Jan 29, 2023